(Photo source)Panic At The Disco dropped their misplaced punctuation (!) in their name, and with it dropped all the emo-glam-synth-theatric pretense that came along with their first release, A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out. Gone also are the obnoxiously long song titles, (“There’s a Good Reason These Tables Aren’t Numbered Honey, You Just Haven’t Thought of It Yet” anyone?), heavy guitars, synth beats and macabre circus histrionics.
Wait, is this even the same band? If you’re unfamiliar with Panic, you might think so. But vocalist/guitarist/keyboardist Brendon Urie assures in the opening track to Pretty. Odd., “We’re So Starving,” “Oh, how it’s been so long/ we’re so sorry we’ve been gone/ we were busy writing songs for…/ you don’t have to worry/ we’re still the same band.” Sure, the members are still the same and some core melodic elements are the same, but Panic At The Disco now sounds more like Beatles At The Hipster Dive.
“Behind The Sea” makes you wonder if “Dear Prudence” has a sardonic atheist twin. Both are similar in sound but lyrically polar opposites. “Do You Know What I’m Seeing?” draws some parallels with “Here Comes The Sun” but while The Beatles are all about their mood being affected by the temperature, Urie says: “I know it’s sad that I never gave a damn about the weather/ and it never gave a damn about me.”
But you’re inclined to think that Panic does indeed give a damn about the weather since Pretty. Odd. carries a celestial motif throughout. If A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out was the band at its darkest and stormiest, then Pretty. Odd. is an overcast day with periodic breaks in the clouds. (Here comes the sun! Oh wait, there it goes. It’s alright.)
“When The Day Met The Night” is an extended metaphor about achieving balance (perhaps through a romance) using the moon and the sun as figurative lovers. “When the moon fell in love with the sun/ all was golden in the sky/ all was golden when the day met the night.” Pretty. Odd. must be the sun to A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out’s moon, then. There are so many parallels to draw... it makes you wonder if Panic At The Disco is amazingly clever or just trying too hard.
If there was a time when they were trying too hard it was in their earlier years. Heavily hyped by emo-pop darlings Fall Out Boy, Panic had an image and a reputation to uphold. Now that they have a fan base, their sophomore album gave the band much more room to grow and experiment. Sophomore slumps be damned because Pretty. Odd. is pretty innovative.
There are two directions that a band can take with its sophomore album. A band can choose to stick with the same formula if it worked with the first album (A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out really popped.) This is the safe and marketable route. Otherwise, a band can choose to tinker with or reinvent its sound to show personal and artistic growth. This can be risky for an artist or group that hasn’t been around for too long. With a three-year hiatus between releasing albums, Panic had plenty of time to tinker and grow. This long break also created a lot of hype and anticipation for the album among those that fell in love with Fever.
The best part of Pretty. Odd. is how complete the album is. Not every song sounds the same. Not every song has the same instrumentation or tempo. The album starts off with the welcome-back-to-our-world anthem “We’re So Starving” (which is strangely similar to The Killer’s “Enterlude” that introduced “Sam’s Town.” And, “Sam’s Town was The Killer’s metamorphosis from synthesizer-driven anthemic rock to something more mellow… hmm.)
“Nine In The Afternoon” is a playful romp, “When The Day Met The Night” is a melancholic lullaby, “Folkin’ Around” is a jam session down the
Despite its superior quality over Fever and musical depth, Panic might run into some problems commercially with Pretty. Odd. One look at the crowds that Panic drew during their first tour would consist of a lot of teenage girls and shaggy-haired sexually-ambiguous males. Stereotypes suggest this crowd wouldn’t be interested in a toned-down folk-influenced foray into melodic indie jamming.
Conversely those into this sort of indie folkishness might be off-put by a new Panic offering with the assumption that it will be the same as their last album. This isn’t really fair though because if Panic was willing to dig deep and find a positive direction in their musical evolution, people should give Pretty. Odd. a chance. But, business is business and music is no exception; hopefully Panic doesn’t fall victim due to their experimentation.





